Pie Flavors & Care Instructions

A shortbread crust cradles a sweet sauce of butter, bourbon, brown sugar, and Texas pecans. You will not find any corn syrup here. Our bakers favor this pie above all the rest, so we consider it our most perfect pie to date. You will never try another pecan pie quite like this one.

Contains wheat (gluten), nuts egg, and dairy ingredients.

Care instructions

Keep sealed and store in a cool, dry place. Do not refrigerate. Pie can be stored frozen in original packaging for up to three weeks.

If frozen, allow the pie to come to room temp. Can be served at room temp or heated in the oven at 350 degrees for 20-30 minutes.

A whopping ten apples are peeled, chopped, and soft-baked into our house-made caramel. Topped with a crispy cinnamon streusel, the buttery, flaky crust rises lord-like above the rest. This delicious tower of tastiness is the tallest pie you have ever met.

Contains wheat (gluten), egg, and dairy ingredients.

Care instructions

Keep sealed. Store in a cool, dry place. Do not refrigerate. For prolonged life, the pie can be stored frozen in its original packaging for up to three weeks.

If frozen, allow the pie to come to room temp. Can be served at room temperature or heated in the oven at 350 degrees for 20-30 minutes.

Silky-sweet chocolate is piped onto a salty pretzel crust and topped with a chocolate rosette. This pie is a chocolate dream for the chocolate dreamer, while the immaculate mixture of salty and sweet will get your saxophones going.

Regular: contains wheat (gluten), soy, egg and dairy ingredients.
Gluten Free: contains soy, egg and dairy ingredients.

Care instructions

Keep sealed and refrigerated until ready to serve. For prolonged life, pie can be stored frozen and wrapped for up to 3 weeks.

We love, love, love the Doctor Love. A red velvet chess pie with the texture of a moist, gooey brownie and the flavor of red velvet cream cheese, this sumptuous pie will make you (and your lover) cry out yes! Rest assured the Dr. Love is a keeper.

Care instructions

Keep sealed until ready to serve. Store in a cool, dry place (refrigeration is not recommended). For prolonged life, the pie can be stored frozen for up to 3 weeks. We recommend wrapping tightly in plastic wrap to preserve freshness. To heat: bake at 425 degrees for 5 minutes for a slice and for 15 minutes (covered) for a whole pie. Please note that heating can cause the Dr. Love to dry out a bit.

This is the star key lime pie you have long been searching for. Sweet, tangy custard and tart key limes take the stage, and if that was not enough, consider our signature whipped cream, cream cheese blend, and our graham cracker crust with a crunch. Now you are dancing with us.

Care instructions

Store in the refrigerator, in the box. This pie should stay refrigerated and should not be heated. For prolonged life, pie can be stored frozen for up to 3 weeks. We recommend wrapping tightly in plastic wrap to preserve freshness.

A heavenly trifecta of house-made caramel, rich and creamy butterscotch custard, and brown-sugar meringue toasted like a marshmallow. This decadent pie is a customer favorite that brings smiles when it arrives each spring, and many tears when it's gone again. With a glass of milk, the flavors are truly divine.

Care instructions

Keep sealed and refrigerated until ready to serve. Expires 3 days from pick-up. We do not recommend freezing the Cloud Nine due to the meringue. This pie should not be heated.

Our blueberry pie is as Texan as the vast blue skies. A classic golden pie crust brimming with fresh blueberries, with just enough sugar to make you smile. A hint of vanilla and lemon gives the classic a bit of a twist, the whole thing latticed with more crust. If you don't have it with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, you are missing out.

Care instructions

Keep sealed until ready to serve. Expires 3 days from pick-up. We do not recommend freezing this pie. To heat: bake at 425 degrees for 6 minutes for a slice and for 15-20 minutes (covered) for a whole pie.

Oak Cliff Coffee + 5 Mile chocolate custard with a handmade toffee sauce nestled in a graham cracker crust. A pie this good it should be outlaw'd. 

Care instructions

Keep sealed and refrigerated until ready to serve. 

BRAND NEW Brownie Points pie is a chocolate brownie pie layered with peanut butter caramel topped with sea salt in an all butter flakey chocolate crust. The name says it all—this pie is a ticket to sweet rewards, offering a perfect balance of sweetness and saltiness that's guaranteed to earn you accolades. 

CARE INSTRUCTIONS

Keep sealed and store in a cool, dry place. Do not refrigerate. Pie can be stored frozen in original packaging for up to three weeks.

If frozen, allow the pie to come to room temp. Can be served at room temp or heated in the oven at 350 degrees for 20-30 minutes.

Carrot cake chess pie is layered with cream cheese and topped with a pecan streusel. It might be described as the love child of a cream cheese, carrot cake muffin, and a pie.

Care instructions
Storage: Keep sealed until ready to serve. Store in a cool, dry place. (refrigeration not recommended)

Reheating: Heating this pie is not recommended and may cause it to dry out.

A delicious sugar cookie pie in a buttery flaky crust. Like all simple things, therein lies its genius. Smooth, sweet, and difficult to stop eating. This sugar cookie in a pie goes excellent with hot coffee.

Contains wheat (gluten), egg, and dairy ingredients.

Care instructions

Keep sealed and store in a cool, dry place. Do not refrigerate. Pie can be stored frozen in original packaging for up to three weeks.

If frozen, allow the pie to come to room temp. Can be served at room temp or heated in the oven at 350 degrees for 20-30 minutes.

Our version of the classic fruit pie that grandma left cooling on her windowsill. The flaky lattices and all butter crust, filled with tart cherries and brown sugar, and just a touch of salt. This is one of our most popular fruit pies. She's a looker too.

Care instructions

Keep sealed until ready to serve. Store in a cool, dry place. (refrigeration not recommended) For prolonged life, pie can be stored frozen for up to 3 weeks. We recommend wrapping tightly in plastic wrap to preserve freshness.

Our classic Chicken Pot Pie stuffed with carrots, onion, peas, herbs, chicken and gravy. Savor this special pie whenever you can because it only makes an appearance twice a year!

To order this pie, select March 14th or September 1st from our Order Page and add Chickin Lickin to your cart.

Care instructions

Eat immediately or store in refrigerator. Pie will last up to 3 days if kept in refrigerator.

Heating Instructions:

Whole Pie: Preheat oven to 350. Place pie on sheet pan and place in oven for 25 - 35min or until heated all the way through.

By the slice: Preheat oven to 400. Place slice on sheet pan and heat for 8 - 10 min or until heated all the way through.

We’re tipping our hats to Lord of the Pies‘ sleeker, slimmer cousin. It features everything you love about our fan favorite, Lord of the Pies - Thinly sliced granny smith apples that are cooked down in our house made caramel sauce, all topped with a crispy cinnamon streusel and sitting in flakey buttery crust.

Care instructions

Keep sealed. Store in a cool, dry place. Do not refrigerate. For prolonged life, the pie can be stored frozen in its original packaging for up to three weeks.

If frozen, allow the pie to come to room temp. Can be served at room temperature or heated in the oven at 350 degrees for 20-30 minutes.

All butter flakey pie crust. Available at grocery stores and pie shops near you.

Par Baking A Crust:

Keep frozen until ready to serve.

1. Preheat ove to 375
2. Place the dough into the pan, centered
3. Crimp the outer rim of the dough
4. Dock the dough to prevent bubbles
5. Place a piece of parchment paper and pie weights in the dough
6. Bake at 375 for 20 minutes
7. Remove the weights
8. Bake again for 10 minutes at 375
9. Fill with delicious pie filling

Baking Pie in the Crust:

1. Place the dough into the pan, centered
2. Crimp the outer rim of the dough
3. Dock the dough to prevent bubbles
4. Fill the dough with your pie filling and bake according to the pie recipe

A gingerbread crust like a delicious cookie and a pumpkin custard filled with cinnamon cloves, this pie will catch your eye (and your nose)! The secret blend of spices added to the smooth sumptuous center makes this holiday favorite "to die for."

Contains wheat (gluten), egg, and dairy ingredients.

Care instructions

Keep sealed and refrigerated. Pie can be stored frozen in original packaging for up to three weeks.

If frozen, allow the pie to come to room temp. Can be served cool or heated in the oven at 350 degrees for 20-30 minutes.

A chocolatey twist on our classic buttermilk pie for those indecisive enthusiasts of both vanilla and chocolate. Our basic buttermilk batter is swirled with Nutella to form a marbled chess pie that will tickle your ivories.

Care instructions

Keep sealed until ready to serve. Store in a cool, dry place. (refrigeration not recommended) For prolonged life, pie can be stored frozen for up to 3 weeks. We recommend wrapping tightly in plastic wrap to preserve freshness.

If Santa had a favorite pie, this would be it. A white chocolate peppermint custard layered with peppermint whip cream. The dark chocolate cookie crust gives it a snap underneath, like presents under a Christmas tree.

Care instructions

This pie should stay refrigerated and should not be heated. The peppermints are made with an all natural dye made from beets so after a day or two the color begins to bleed. It'll still taste great but begin to change in appearance. Keep sealed until ready to serve. For prolonged life, pie can be stored frozen for up to 3 weeks. We recommend wrapping tightly in plastic wrap to preserve freshness.

A rare appearance of our delightful hand pies comes once a year at Father's Day. This set includes the following flavors:
• Blueberry with Sweet Corn Frosting
• Strawberry Balsamic with Goat Cheese Frosting
• Brown Sugar with a Cinnamon Glaze

To order these hand pies, select June 18th, 19th or 20th from our Ordering Page and add Hand Pies to your cart.

Nationwide shipping available via Goldbelly.

Imagine the nostalgic charm of an old-fashioned donut meeting the comforting essence of poppyseed bread in each slice. The pie boasts a rich, buttery chess pie filling, generously speckled with poppyseeds for a delightful crunch and a subtle nutty undertone. The sweetness of the pie is balanced by the zesty brightness of the orange glaze.

Care instructions

Keep sealed until ready to serve. Store in a cool, dry place (refrigeration is not recommended). For prolonged life, the pie can be stored frozen for up to 3 weeks. We recommend wrapping tightly in plastic wrap to preserve freshness. To heat: bake at 425 degrees for 5 minutes for a slice and for 15 minutes (covered) for a whole pie. Please note that heating can cause the pie to dry out.

Nothing stacks up to this pancake-inspired pie! Our classic buttermilk pie is layered with rich, house-made salted maple caramel. It tastes like the perfect pancake!

Care instructions

We prefer this pie at room temperature, but if you would like to heat it, do so in the oven at 425 degrees for 5 minutes for a slice and for 15 minutes (covered) for a whole pie. Please note that with the Hot Cake, heating can cause the pie to dry out a bit. Keep sealed until ready to serve. Store in a cool, dry place. (refrigeration not recommended) For prolonged life, pie can be stored frozen for up to 3 weeks. We recommend wrapping tightly in plastic wrap to preserve freshness.

Queen of summertime, this light fluffy lemon-chiffon pie is a combination of sweet and tart that melts in your mouth. The light airy custard is enthroned in a crunchy gingersnap crust. The result is a regal refreshment to keep the summertime heat at bay.

Care instructions

Keep sealed and refrigerated until ready to serve. For prolonged life, pie can be stored frozen for up to 3 weeks. We recommend wrapping tightly in plastic wrap to preserve freshness.

Snow matter how you slice it, this pie will top your list of favorites! Our cookies & cream custard is topped with cream cheese whipped topping. All of this goodness is cradled in a rich chocolate cookie crust.

Care Instructions:

This pie should stay refrigerated and should not be heated.

Meet the Merry Berry. It is not quite pie, not quite muffin, not quite cobbler... but it IS quite delicious. The layers of sugar-cookie-muffin batter are mixed with tart cranberries and sugary pecans. It's like a chess pie and a cranberry muffin had a baby.

Care instructions

To heat: In the oven at 425 degrees for 6 minutes for a slice and for 15-20 minutes (covered) for a whole pie. Make sure you put it on a cookie sheet! Keep sealed until ready to serve. Store in a cool, dry place. (refrigeration not recommended) For prolonged life, pie can be stored frozen for up to 3 weeks. We recommend wrapping tightly in plastic wrap to preserve freshness.

Do you know the Muffin Man? The layers of cream cheese swirled muffin batter are mixed with tart blueberries and hint of lemon. Notes of vanilla, and lemon zest make this pie something to sing about.

Care instructions

Keep sealed until ready to serve. Store in a cool, dry place (refrigeration is not recommended). For prolonged life, the pie can be stored frozen for up to 3 weeks. We recommend wrapping tightly in plastic wrap to preserve freshness.

Nutty Honey is our peanut butter lover. A salted layer of honey-nut sauce and peanut butter cream filling topped with house-whipped cream and crushed honey-roasted peanuts. The crumbly graham cracker crust makes crunchy the new sexy. You hate to watch the Nutty Honey go, but love to watch her leave.

Contains wheat (gluten), nuts, tree nuts, soy, egg, and dairy ingredients.

Care instructions

Keep sealed and refrigerated until ready to serve. For prolonged life, pie can be stored frozen in original packaging for up to 3 weeks.

Papa Don’t Peach 🍑 is the perfect summer pie: tart & sweet cream pie with plenty of peaches and raspberries, topped with cinnamon streusel and bundled up in a buttery, flaky crust! Mmmm.

Care instructions

This pie should stay refrigerated and should not be heated. For prolonged life, pie can be stored frozen for up to 3 weeks. We recommend wrapping tightly in plastic wrap to preserve freshness.

Brown sugar peach cobbler topped with a lattice topping, just like your grandma made it. If you don't have it with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, you are missing out.

Care instructions

Keep sealed until ready to serve. Store in a cool, dry place. (refrigeration not recommended) For prolonged life, pie can be stored frozen for up to 3 weeks. We recommend wrapping tightly in plastic wrap to preserve freshness.

Care instructions

Keep sealed until ready to serve. Store in a cool, dry place. (refrigeration not recommended) For prolonged life, pie can be stored frozen for up to 3 weeks. We recommend wrapping tightly in plastic wrap to preserve freshness.

A rich brownie filling on a graham crumbles crust with marshmallow meringue fluff and sprinkles on top.

Care instructions

Marshmallow meringue can be stored at room temperature for several hours, but is best stored refrigerated for extended periods of time.

A fluffy cloud-like custard is topped with crispy coconut crumbles. This winter pie picks up momentum with every bite. Coconut lovers will dream of the pure, powdery texture, white as a slice of snowflake.

Care instructions

This pie should stay refrigerated and should not be heated. Keep sealed until ready to serve. For prolonged life, pie can be stored frozen for up to 3 weeks. We recommend wrapping tightly in plastic wrap to preserve freshness.

Our delicious strawberry, raspberry rhubarb pie. Only available on June 25th each year.

Care instructions

Store sealed in a container on the counter. Best by 2 days from pick-up.

We’ve layered cinnamon roll spread with creamy vanilla custard, topped it with a cream cheese whipped cream topping, and nestled it all in a Lorna Doone cookie crust. This pie is sweet, like cinnamon. 

Care instructions

Keep sealed and refrigerated until ready to serve. For prolonged life, pie can be stored frozen in original packaging for up to 3 weeks.

A banana cream pie blooming with a rich custard filling that resembles crème pâtissière, a key component of various French cakes and tarts (ooh la la). The Nannerz is layered with sliced bananas, vanilla, and house-made maple caramel, then topped with house-made whipped cream.

Contains wheat (gluten), egg, and dairy ingredients.

Care instructions

Keep sealed and refrigerated until ready to serve. For prolonged life, pie can be stored frozen in original packaging for up to 3 weeks.

Ingredient List:

Flour, Sugar, Salt, Butter, Lemon Juice, Egg, Heavy Cream, Ground pepper, Cottage Cheese, Gruyere Cheese, Spinach, Shallot

Reheating Instructions:

1. Reheating Whole Pie: Preheat oven to 350°. Place on sheet pan, in oven for 25 - 35 min or until heated all the way through.
2. Reheating Slice: Preheat oven to 400°. Place slice on a sheet pan in oven for 8-10 minutes or until heated all the way through.

A Valentine's Day gift box of mini pies, including Dr. Love, Ebony & Ivory, S'morgasbord, Buttercream Gang, and Hot Cake.

To order these mini pies, select February 11th to 14th from our Ordering Page and add Valenpies to your cart.

Yippee Pie Yay, is here to celebrate all of life's moments with a crustworthy pie.This thaw-and-serve frozen pie is a confetti sprinkle vanilla chess pie in an all-butter flakey crust.  

For life's special moments, this whole pie is available year round for pick-up in stores & pre-order online. Simply thaw & serve it for an easy, hap-pie celebration!

Contains wheat (gluten), egg, and dairy ingredients. This pie is made in a small kitchen with nuts.

Care instructions

This pie comes frozen. Keep frozen until ready to eat.

When you are ready to eat, take the pie out of the shrink wrap. Thaw the pie at room temperature. Pie will be ready to serve within 4-6 hours. Once thawed, pie is good for 5 days stored at room temperature.

Imagine the nostalgic charm of an old-fashioned donut meeting the comforting essence of poppyseed bread in each slice. The pie boasts a rich, buttery chess pie filling, generously speckled with poppyseeds for a delightful crunch and a subtle nutty undertone. The sweetness of the pie is balanced by the zesty brightness of the orange glaze.

CARE INSTRUCTIONS

Keep sealed until ready to serve. Store in a cool, dry place (refrigeration is not recommended). For prolonged life, the pie can be stored frozen for up to 3 weeks. We recommend wrapping tightly in plastic wrap to preserve freshness.

To heat: bake at 425 degrees for 5 minutes for a slice and for 15 minutes (covered) for a whole pie. Please note that heating can cause the pie to dry out.